Well, it's been a long time since I have posted to this blog. I figured with Vista's release coming soon and seeing as how I have been testing it and using for the past couple months I would touch upon that and Office 2007. Ok, so despite my best intentions to hate Vista, I don't. I like it, and I think it's definitely a worthwhile and much needed replacement operating system. Will I embrace it with open arms when it releases at the end of January? Short answer is no, but I figure I don't use it on a daily basis and I have a working copy until June (RC1) so I am going to wait until then to purchase Vista. Besides Crysis isn't coming out until the end of 2007, and it could be delayed.
Do I think that everyone should go out and buy Vista right away, no I don't. I think that it would serve most people well to wait. Wait for at least 6 months or a year if you can. I do like Vista and there is definitely some really neat and some awesome features. The new security is a definitely plus, the updates to group policy are nice and WIM or Windows Image Manager is one of the best features. It allows a person to make an image of a Vista install and use that image to deploy it multiple computers. I think it will be very useful for organizations that need to deploy many Vista machines. And how could I forget DX10 I have tested Vista as a gaming platform and I have to say it felt just like I was gaming on XP, which is a good thing seeing as I was using a pre-release build. Another nice thing is the inclusion of parental controls.
As with all things there are downsides. UAC, which is supposed to protect people from either unintentionally doing something that could harm the computer to protecting them from things happening in the background such as silent software installs or scripts. Right now those of you that haven't used Vista are thinking yeah that sounds great, and I tell you it is great, except that for everything Windows dectects it needs to confer with the user as to whether or not the user initiated this action. While the user is making their choice Windows brings the OS to a halt, which is fine, in fact very secure. It just seems that there are a lot of things that need my ok. I will be honest, it doesn't bother me personally that much. However, I think those that like things to just "work" will find themselves getting a little annoyed with the extra mouse clicks. It should also be noted that you can turn this feature off, but Microsoft does not recommend such action and neither do I.
Another peg against the OS is more from a vendor point of view, but if a person buys the 64-bit Vista they cannot install any unsigned drivers. So for those of you that like Omega video card drivers or any other homebrew drivers stick to the 32-bit Vista. Some anti-virus companies have claimed anti-trust against Microsoft for not allowing them to patch the kernel and therefore rendering their anti-virus useless on 64-bit systems. So for those of you who need a 64-bit OS, just keep in mind that your anti-virus choices will be limited. I have to dock points from Microsoft for the inclusion of the "PatchGuard" technology in the 64-bit OS. I mean it's only a matter of time before the bad guys figure out a way around it and I am sure that the bad guys will figure this out before the good guys, so in a way the only thing Microsoft did was disallow customization with alterative flavor drivers and potentially open 64-bit Vista users to security risks while severely limiting their protection options. I understand why Microsoft included the feature, but they really should give malware and virus writers a bit more credit.
I do need to include a little blip about parental controls. In my opinion and in many parents' eyes this feature is long overdue. I applaud Microsoft for allowing parents such controls over how the OS and IE works, however, it could be a bit clearer. I was able to set up controls with relative ease, however I think doing the same for any normal parent with limited technical knowledge will be much more difficult and confusing. I think they would have been better off using a wizard with simplified definitions by default with the control panel applet as an option. It should also be mentioned that parental controls are only available in Vista Ultimate version. So I am sure parents will buy it and the less technically knowledgeable will eventually give up trying to configure it. Hopefully, Microsoft puts out some documentation on how to configure it.
Another small tidbit is program incompatibility. Anyone who has been reading knows that there have been a lot of program incompatibility issues. This is a big part of why I said I would wait. Chances are after release the program incompatibilities will lessen. Not only that but by waiting a lot of security issues and other problems that crop up after a release will be fixed.
My last point is Aeroglass. This is the new look of Windows. Does it look good? Yes, it does and it adds some effects like transparency, flip and flip 3d. Do I like it? Well, this is a complicated question. I think it's highly overrated, it looks good, but none of the effects warrant needing a DX9 video card. For all the build-up and talk when I saw it, I thought 'hmm...that's it huh'. It didn't blow me away. I do like that the entire desktop is rendered so that windows will not stay on the desktop due to the processor being busy. That always annoyed me about XP. Sometimes when a program became unresponsive the window would stay up until the program was closed, preventing access to the desktop. Well, no longer now you can always access your desktop regardless of what is unresponsive. I will probably use it just to get familiar with it and then ditch it in favor of the classic interface. I didn't like the XP interface either so I currently use classic.
Well, I do realize that I spent a lot more time on the negative than the positive, but I will be honest most of the changes that I like have to do with kernel level changes, not so much changes to the look and feel. I typically do not like changes to the look and feel of something that is already functional. Vista is not perfect, however I can say that it has a lot more going for it coming out of the gate than XP did. All in all, it will be a great OS not right away but 6 months from now, it will definitely warrant purchase.
Signing off,
Kris